• Home
  • Electrical Switchboards
  • Testing & Commissioning
  • Engineering Services
  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • Electrical Switchboards
  • Testing & Commissioning
  • Engineering Services
  • Contact Us

  • Home
  • 8 February 2023
  • Electrical Switchboard Manufacturer | Technical Articles

How Do Different ECB Brands Compare in Performance?

ECB (Electronic circuit breakers) plays an important part of the advanced electrical systems used in contemporary buildings, with safety against overloads, short circuits, and other electrical faults. The major manufacturers of ECBs include Schneider Electric, ABB, Terasaki, LS Electric, and Siemens. Their products differ in each company; however, some have special demands based on either industrial or commercial usage or residential purposes.

Schneider Electric: ComPact NSX Range

Schneider Electric’s ComPact NSX series is a range of molded case circuit breakers (MCCBs) for low-voltage applications up to 630 A. The range is available with both thermal-magnetic and advanced MicroLogic electronic trip units, providing accurate protection and energy management. Integrated earth leakage protection enhances safety, making these breakers ideal for industrial, commercial, and critical infrastructure applications.

The ComPact NSX range is a product that is unique because of the monitoring of real-time data, and facility managers can optimize energy efficiency. The trip units are available with a set of communication modules that allow for easy integration into building management systems. The breaking capacities of breakers vary between 25 kA and 200 kA at 415 V, providing robust protection for different operating conditions. Additionally, the compact size and modular accessory contribute to installation ease and flexibility. Therefore, in most applications, ComPact NSX series stands as the best among them.

Schneider Electric comes up with its ComPact NSX series, which represents a series of AC and DC circuit breakers and switch-disconnectors. The company within this range does have products to be applied for low-voltage DC distribution systems and PV application.

ComPact NSX has up to 100 kA at 690 V breaking capacity, up to 690 V. There are 1, 2, 3, and 4-pole versions available. Trip units are interchangeable, allowing for easy upgrades with new functions. It has a wide range of accessories, including insulation series and parallel connection accessories, which increase its capabilities. The range is designed according to international standards, namely IEC 60947-1 and 2, and IEC 68230.

It is possible to apply the ComPact NSX range for lines up to 630 amps for protection. It is also a suitable option for low-voltage DC distribution systems and may be applied in PV applications.

ABB: SACE Tmax XT Series

The MCCBs, specifically the SACE Tmax XT series, by ABB are particularly targeted for low-voltage networks up to 1600 A and emphasizes reliability in protection. These units have been designed keeping in mind improved connectivity and digital integration, along with the smart monitoring capability of ABB’s Ekip Touch and Ekip Hi-Touch trip units. Electronic trip units enable adjustment in protection settings as well as in measurement of energy and system diagnostics, thereby ensuring less down time and maximum operational productivity.

The Tmax XT line frames come in different sizes such as XT1, XT2, XT3, and XT4 among many others with different breaking capacities and options. The breakers are cloud friendly, IoT ready, and fit modern industrial automation. Add-on accessories that include auxiliary contacts, undervoltage releases, and shunt trips among other optional variants can also be offered on this line. The Tmax XT series by ABB is extensively used in commercial buildings, industrial plants, and energy distribution networks because of its flexibility and superior protection features.

Tmax XT molded case circuit breakers guarantee an extremely high level of performance but are constantly smaller in size, easy to install, and can provide ever better safety. The range is rounded off by four frame sizes: XT1, XT2 up to 160 A, and XT3, XT4 up to 250 A.

The Tmax XT series provides high breaking capacity in compact dimensions. It allows savings in copper and footprint in switchboards, high selectivity values, and very compact motor protection solutions through its extraordinary limiting characteristics. This product ensures ease of use and installation flexibility with a dedicated range of accessories and a renewed solution for electronic trip units, adapting it to the various application scenarios. Customized protective information availability comes through specific electronic trip units designed for energy metering, motor protection, as well as the generator protection accompanied by a communication module based on Modbus. The operators could be assured with higher safety aspects through a variety of key lock and padlock options, offering plug-in or withdrawable configurations to speed up the maintenance processes, and excellent diagnostics for closed monitoring of breaker status in real-time.

Terasaki TemBreak 2 Series

Terasaki TemBreak 2 brand can be taken to be one of the high standards in safety as well as good performance. The MCCBs are available within the range of this brand ranging from rated currents 20 A to 1600 A while the breaking capacities are between 25 kA to 200 kA at 415 V AC. Direct opening action is used by the TemBreak 2 breakers that disconnect really fast during an electrical fault hence risks are always associated with both short circuits as well as the overloads.

Field-installable accessories in the TemBreak 2 series are one of its most prominent features, where engineers can make the breakers according to specific application requirements. The switch-disconnectors within the same compact frame sizes complete the electrical protection solutions in this series. They are widely used in manufacturing, marine, and energy distribution applications, where safety and reliability are paramount. The ease of maintenance and high breaking capacity make them a preferred choice for demanding environments.

LS Electric: Metasol Series

LS Electric manufactures the Metasol MCCBs, which are designed to offer high-performance protection for industrial and commercial applications. The Metasol series protects against overloads, short circuits, and leakage currents through MCCBs and Earth Leakage Circuit Breakers, which come in various frame sizes and have adjustable trip settings to meet specific safety and operating requirements.

Siemens: 3VA Molded Case Circuit Breakers

The 3VA series includes a wide MCCB with varied distribution of low voltages in the range from 15 to 2000 A, features both thermal-magnetic and electronic trip units. Thus, even for general applications as well as challenging applications suitable for conformance and compliance by various industries according to worldwide-accepted standards including IEC and UL.

We design and manufacture high-quality switchboards. Contact us today to discuss your requirements and get started!

Tags: switchboards
Electrical Switchboard Manufacturer
  • BESS & Batteries
  • Electric Vehicles & EV Charging Switchboards
  • Electrical Enclosures
  • Engineering Resources
  • High & Medium Voltage
  • Integrating Diesel & Backup Generation
  • Power Quality Analysis
  • Protection Relays & Injection Testing
  • Renewable Energy & Power Generation
  • Solar Standards: AS/NZS 4777 2024
  • Switchboards & Components
  • Virtual Power Plants & Smart Grids
  • Wiring Rules AS/NZS 3000
  • electrical switchboard | electrical switchboards
    What is Edge Computing? How it helps power distribution?
    Edge computing refers to an arrangement where data processing occurs… Read more: What is Edge Computing? How it helps power distribution?
  • electrical switchboard | electrical switchboards
    What is Net Zero Building? How it uses Smart Switchboards?
    Net Zero building is designed in a way that allows… Read more: What is Net Zero Building? How it uses Smart Switchboards?
  • electrical switchboard | electrical switchboards
    What is Paralleling Switchgear? How it works?
    Paralleling switchgear is basically a low-voltage switchboard used to control… Read more: What is Paralleling Switchgear? How it works?
  • electrical switchboard | electrical switchboards
    What is Electrification? Understanding the Basics
    Electrification is turning into one of the major trends in… Read more: What is Electrification? Understanding the Basics
  • What is a Data Center?
    What Is a Data Center? Discover How it works!
    DATA CENTER – Each day, we use the internet and… Read more: What Is a Data Center? Discover How it works!
  • 250A Chassis
    Understanding a 250A Chassis in a Distribution Board
    A 250A chassis is an example of a type of… Read more: Understanding a 250A Chassis in a Distribution Board
  • arc flash protection
    Arc Flash Protection – What Really Happens When Systems Fail
    The technician didn’t hear anything unusual. No alarm. No warning.… Read more: Arc Flash Protection – What Really Happens When Systems Fail
  • Do All Switchboards Require a Dedicated Room?
    Do All Switchboards Require a Dedicated Room?
    Switchboards are usually mounted on a garage wall, sometimes in… Read more: Do All Switchboards Require a Dedicated Room?
  • Is SMA leaving the Australian market?
    Why is SMA shutting down in Australia? Explained!
    Is SMA really going to close down? SMA’s move in… Read more: Why is SMA shutting down in Australia? Explained!
  • electrical switchboard | electrical switchboards
    What Are Electronic Overload Relays? Explained!
    Electronic overload relay sends a signal to the contactor to… Read more: What Are Electronic Overload Relays? Explained!
  • electrical switchboard | electrical switchboards
    AS/NZS 3000 Switchboard Rules – Complete Guide for Compliance and Safety
    Switchboard rules is critical for ensuring electrical safety and functionality.… Read more: AS/NZS 3000 Switchboard Rules – Complete Guide for Compliance and Safety
  • electrical switchboard | electrical switchboards
    AS/NZS 3000 Switchboard Clearances: Safety Rules Every Electrician Must Know
    Ensuring proper switchboard clearances is crucial for maintaining safety and… Read more: AS/NZS 3000 Switchboard Clearances: Safety Rules Every Electrician Must Know

Contact Us

Phone: 02 9558 2480

Email: contact@cleantechcontrols.com.au

Sales (VIC) 0435 812 094

Sales (NSW) 0405 352 840

Sales (WA) 0419 423 609

Useful Links

  • Home
  • Electrical Switchboards
  • Injection Testing & PQA
  • Engineering Services
  • Technical Articles
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
© 2020 Clean Technology Controls. All Rights Reserved.